Villanova is now an Antiracist University - is that a bad thing?

-

Rod Dreher wrote an article published in The American Conservative titled "What's Happening To Villanova."*  Mr. Dreher provides a copy of a letter published by Father President Peter Donohue and then Mr. Dreher goes on to rip into the University because of the letter.

If the only evidence is what is said in Father Peter's message, and that is the only evidence Mr. Dreher offers, then I have to disagree with Mr. Dreher's interpretation.  Here is an alternative view of what Father Peter said:  

- We want Villanova to be antiracist.  Good.  I'm against racism and I'm glad Villanova is too.

- Antiracist means justice and equity for everyone.  I really like that comment.  When the phrase "Black Lives Matter" first became popular didn't many people (including myself at the time) respond, "All Lives Matter."  Here we have Father Peter saying antiracist doesn't mean we should try to protect one group of people, it means we should try to protect all people.  I agree with that 100%.

- Compassion and empathy to Asian Americans due to the events in Atlanta.  What do we expect from a Catholic Priest who heads a Catholic University?  Do we expect him to say "screw them, the <insert racially derogatory name here>, I never liked them anyway?"  Of course not, we expect him to say exactly what he said.  And why shouldn't we all say that? 

- Regarding LGBTQAI+, he wants all people to feel welcome at Villanova, particularly those who have suffered exclusion.  Isn't that what the Church is all about?  Hasn't the Catholic Church been held out as a place of "sanctuary" through history?  Perhaps that concept has been idealized, and maybe the Church hasn't always lived up to it, but it is the ideal and good for Father Peter saying Villanova wants to adhere to that ideal.  Personally, I don't hate LGBTQAI+ individuals.  I don't agree with the political views of some of them or their organizations, but I would not want to see any of them come to harm physically, emotionally or otherwise.  They are still Americans and they have rights just like all other Americans.  Kudos to Father Peter saying Villanova doesn't want them to be harmed either.

- "Understanding those around us will help us do everything we do here at Villanova better."  He's right.  Understanding others and their problems can make what we do so much better than the name calling and smears and cancel culture environment we currently endure because people don't want to take the time to listen and understand.

The author of the article says "To be an 'antiracist' campus is to embrace the crackpot neoracist ideology of Ibram X. Kendi."  I'm curious what law, regulation, or other requirement requires Villanova to embrace that ideology?  Is it a federal, state or local law that requires a college that wants to be antiracist to embrace that ideology?  Or is it in the Catholic Church canon?  Of course not.  

But let's be realistic, the author's concerns are not unfounded.  Given what we have seen on college campuses in the last decade, I think we have reason to be vigilant in watching what happens next at Villanova.  But Father Peter's message was only issued last Friday.  Now we need to watch and see what Villanova does and whether they live up to his words.  

Will the University really enforce justice and equity for everyone or just provide justice and equity for preferred groups and individuals?  For example, will conservatives be protected the same as progressives?  Will individuals accused of sexual misconduct be found guilty without due process?  Will white people be according justice and equity and protected from the kinds of false accusations and abusive behavior we saw some subjected to at Smith College?** 

I think the better course of action as a concerned Alumni is to applaud Father President Donohue and remind him that "words matter" and encourage him and the University to live up to exactly what he said - equality and justice for all. 



---------


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Biden Legacy

-
This week President Biden gave a speech reviewing his legacy in the White House.  Biden talked about the good he's done.  I have a different perspective, I see the deaths and damage that occurred in the last four years. Covid - more people died of Covid in 2021, when Biden was in office, than died in 2020, when Trump was in office.*  In 2020, the disease was new and testing was ramping up, treatment protocols were being developed, medical supplies like ventilators were in short supply, and multiple Democrat run States put in place nursing home rules that led to significant numbers of deaths.  In 2021, those nursing home rules were no longer in place, multiple vaccines were available, testing and supply issues had been overcome.  Despite those advantages, more people died of Covid in President Biden's first year in office. The Border - Laken Riley, Rebecca Morin, Jeremy Poou Caceres (a 2 year old boy), Rachel Morin, Melissa Powell and her son Riordan Powell, Ai...
Read more

H-1B Visas - theory versus reality

-
H-1B Visas are a good idea in theory.  People around the world want to come to the United States to work and live.  Why not invite the best and brightest.  Bring top talent to the US to help our businesses, industry and military remain the top in the world. Then there is that pesky thing called reality.  I've worked for small companies with less than 250 employees and companies with hundreds of thousands of employees, and companies in between.  I've seen the reality I'm describing. I'm sure there are some brilliant researchers and developers who have come to the US under this program.  But they are the exception.  The norm is that companies don't bring over the best and the brightest.  They bring over cheap labor.  Companies, seeking to get a leg up on opponents by offering customers lower prices, import labor who will work at a fraction of the cost of US residents doing the same jobs. If a person from Country X is doing the same job an Ameri...
Read more

The Biden Administration blew it on Covid

-
 It's about a year now since Joe Biden was sworn in as President and we can see the Biden Administration has handled the Coronavirus situation horribly.  The Administration had a fantastic opportunity to declare victory early in 2021 and put this behind us.  But they chose not to do that.  The Biden Administration dropped the ball on pursuing the things America needs to put Covid in the rear view mirror while offering a message of fear and dictatorial mandates, and wedding themselves to a bureaucrat who declared that he is the science.  The result was more Covid 19 deaths in 2021 than in 2020, strong disagreement and a loss of public confidence in the measures promoted by the Biden Administration, none of which is good for America. But it didn't have to be this way.  The Biden Administration took office with three different vaccines available to issue to the public and almost 1 million people getting the jab every day.  Shortly after taking office, Con...
Read more