Skip to main content

Calling out Politifact for being Politically Incorrect

The text below is from an email I sent to Politifact pointing out an incorrect fact check of a statement by President Trump and calling on them to retract and correct it.  I'm not holding my breath.

Ken Fody kenfody@gmail.com
to TruthOMeter,
https://twitter.com/PolitiFact/status/1171215126302732288 

Above is a link to your tweet about President Trump's comment.  I'm appalled but not surprised that you ignored what the President really said and fact checked something completely different.  Your action showed laziness and sloppiness at best, and complete bias at worst.  You should issue a retraction and correction.

Your article of February 20th has a headline as follows: "Trump falsely claims Northam said he'd let doctors execute newborns."  You rated the President's comment as false because "Northam, a physician, never said he would sanction the execution of newborns."  

So on February 20 (link below), you carefully reviewed the President's choice of words and used that to rate his statement false.  


Why didn't you use the same care in reviewing the President's choice of words on Monday?  

In your tweet, you quote the President as saying Gov. Northam said "after the baby was born the Dr. will talk to the mother and make a decision about whether the baby lives."  

That statement should be rated True.

In your own article of February 20, you quote Governor Northam as saying "The infant would be resuscitated if that's what the mother and the family desired, and then a discussion would ensue between the physicians and the mother." 

President Trump's comment is 100 percent consistent with what YOU said Governor Northam said until the last words "make a decision about whether the baby lives."  Given the fact that the Governor said the physicians and the mother planned to have a discussion, it's not an unrealistic leap to say they are going to discuss whether efforts will be made to keep the baby alive.  

Words matter.  The President changed what he said and his comment should be rated based on what he actually said.  Going by what the President actually did say - as you quoted it - the President's statement is true.  Your linking to the previous deserves a retraction and a correction.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Biden Administration blew it on Covid

 It's about a year now since Joe Biden was sworn in as President and we can see the Biden Administration has handled the Coronavirus situation horribly.  The Administration had a fantastic opportunity to declare victory early in 2021 and put this behind us.  But they chose not to do that.  The Biden Administration dropped the ball on pursuing the things America needs to put Covid in the rear view mirror while offering a message of fear and dictatorial mandates, and wedding themselves to a bureaucrat who declared that he is the science.  The result was more Covid 19 deaths in 2021 than in 2020, strong disagreement and a loss of public confidence in the measures promoted by the Biden Administration, none of which is good for America. But it didn't have to be this way.  The Biden Administration took office with three different vaccines available to issue to the public and almost 1 million people getting the jab every day.  Shortly after taking office, Congress passed a Covid relie
Post a Comment
Read more

Republicans shouldn't get cocky

Is there anyone who doesn't think the Republicans will retake control of both the U.S. House and Senate this year?  Probably not - and that's the problem.    All the polls we see are generic.  They are asking questions about how people feel about the parties.  The pollsters are asking would a generic Republican defeat a generic Democrat.  Other polls are gauging people's feelings toward President Biden.  Every indication is the Republicans will win big in both Houses of Congress.  What could go wrong? Elections are not generic.  Incumbents are not easy to unseat.  Furthermore, elections involve Candidate A running against Candidate B in specific districts on specific issues.  Candidates and parties also need money to run campaigns. Republicans can be facing an uphill fight on some or all of these points. Take incumbency - in Georgia a recent poll showed Herschel Walker running only a couple of points ahead of Democrat incumbent Senator Raphael Warnock.  These poll results a
Post a Comment
Read more

Inflation stays until Biden and the Democrats go

We won't put inflation behind us as long as Joe Biden is President and Democrats control one or both Houses of Congress.  There was going to be some level of inflation after the shutdowns of 2020, but the policies adopted by the Biden Administration and the spending bills passed by the Democrat Congress have elevated inflation to levels they have not been at in many years.  As long as Joe Biden is in the White House or Democrats control one House of Congress they will be able to prevent undoing the policies that have put us where we are. Starting on day one, the Biden Administration began adopting policies that fueled the growth of inflation.  Despite it being obvious for months that inflation was running hotter than expected the Biden Administration was in denial, saying inflation was transitory.   Supply chain issues were initially caused by other factors but the Biden Administration has talked about addressing this but none of their policies have been successful.   On the other
Post a Comment
Read more